Car Insurance Shrewsbury – Agents with Offices in the Town

26 January 2024

Shrewsbury’s Premier Motor Insurance Providers: Your Comprehensive Guide to Car Insurance Shrewsbury Agents with Offices

Finding the right car insurance in Shrewsbury has never been easier when you use our list below. Our curated list of Shrewsbury motor insurers showcases the top providers in the area, each offering unique motor policy coverage tailored to your needs from their business premises in Shrewsbury.

Car Insurance Shrewsbury with Offices in the Town: A Personal Touch in the Digital Age

Car insurer holding papers illustration.In an era dominated by online transactions and digital interfaces, the charm and reliability of personal, face-to-face service remain unparalleled, especially when it comes to something as crucial as car insurance.

This article caters to those in Shrewsbury who yearn for the old-fashioned, personal touch of local office interactions over the impersonal nature of internet-based services.

It’s tailored for individuals who value real conversations with knowledgeable professionals, offering a sense of security and trust that only human interaction can provide.

While online car insurance comparison websites boast convenience and speed, they often lack the personal connection and nuanced understanding that comes with dealing with real people. These websites provide a broad-strokes approach to insurance, focusing on price comparisons and generic coverage options.

In contrast, local offices in the historic market town of Shrewsbury offer a personalized experience. Here, insurance is not just about numbers and algorithms but about understanding individual needs, offering tailored advice, and building relationships.

The difference lies in the experience – the warmth of a handshake, the reassurance of a familiar face, and the confidence of knowing that your unique circumstances are truly understood and catered for.

1. Howden Insurance Shrewsbury Branch

  • New Identity: Formerly known as A-Plan, Howden continues to uphold its commitment to quality service.
  • Location: 8 High Street, Shrewsbury, SY1 1SP.
  • Contact: 01743 455 900.
  • Operating Hours: Open Monday to Friday from 08:30 to 17:00, and Saturday from 09:00 to 12:00.
  • Branch Manager: Meet Chris Beane, dedicated to providing the best insurance solutions.

2. Coversure Shrewsbury

  • Independent Brokerage: Expertise in business, commercial vehicle, and property insurance since 2001.
  • Local Touch: A blend of online, telephonic, and face-to-face personal service.
  • Location: 6 Castle Gates, Shrewsbury, SY1 2AE.
  • Contact: 01743 598502.
  • Business Hours: Monday to Friday, 9am–5pm.

3. Darwin Insurance

  • Local Expert: Tracy Coates brings over 25 years of experience in Shropshire.
  • One-Stop-Shop: Comprehensive services for home, car, and business insurance needs.
  • Convenient Location: Visit the town centre office at 24 St John’s Hill, Shrewsbury.
  • Contact: 01743 363 363.
  • Accessibility: Open 9am – 5pm, no appointment necessary.


  • Established Presence: Serving clients for over 50 years, with the Shrewsbury branch opening in 2015.
  • Comprehensive Coverage: Offers a wide range of insurances, including car, home, commercial, and more.
  • Expert Team: Providing personalized advice and claims management.
  • Location: 8 High Street, Shrewsbury, SY1 1SP.
  • Contact: 01743 455900.
  • Opening Times: Weekdays 08:30-17:00, Saturday 09:00-12:00.

5. Henshalls Insurance Brokers

  • Dedicated Service: Specializing in private motor insurance for over 30 years.
  • Extensive Network: Access to over 100 private car products from leading insurers.
  • Client-Centric Approach: Offers professional advice and competitive pricing.
  • Location: 1 Brassey Road, Old Potts Way, Shrewsbury, Shropshire SY3 7FA.
  • Contact: 01743 231 091.

6. NFU Mutual

  • Personalized Experience: Providing a friendly, professional, and local service.
  • Broad Offerings: Catering to a diverse range of customer needs including motor insurance.
  • Location: Mutual House, Sitka Drive, Shrewsbury Business Park, Shrewsbury, SY2 6LG.
  • Contact: 01743 818105.

Whether you’re seeking personal, business, or specialized insurance services, Shrewsbury’s top providers are equipped to meet all your needs. Explore these options to ensure you receive the best coverage and customer service experience.

Concluding Note: Navigating Car Insurance in Shrewsbury

Car insurance agent cartoon humourThis comprehensive guide has provided an invaluable resource for those seeking a more personal approach to car insurance in Shrewsbury.

By highlighting the top motor insurance providers in the town, this article has emphasized the importance of human interaction and personalized service in an increasingly digital world. Each of the featured insurance offices, from Howden Insurance to NFU Mutual, offers a unique combination of local expertise, personalized advice, and a broad range of car insurance products, ensuring that every individual’s insurance needs can be met with a personal touch.

In conclusion, while online platforms may offer convenience, they cannot replicate the tailored experience and understanding that comes from engaging with local insurance experts in Shrewsbury. For those who prefer the reassurance of face-to-face interactions and the reliability of established local offices, these Shrewsbury-based insurance providers represent the best in the business. They not only provide comprehensive coverage options but also embody the value of personal connections in the insurance industry.

This guide serves as a starting point for anyone in Shrewsbury looking to navigate the world of car insurance with the support of trusted, local professionals.

Please note: While we strive to provide accurate and up-to-date information, details such as contact numbers, addresses, opening times, and services may change. We recommend verifying with the respective insurance providers for the most current information.

Supporting Small and Medium-Sized Businesses in Shropshire

Affordable Advertising for Local Businesses. Either go for free, for a valuable “citation” or pay for a manually curated business listing.